Posts in "Somalia"

Bonnie Kristian's picture
By Bonnie Kristian at 6:38PM

A short and incomplete summary of why our foreign policy cannot continue as it has for the last decade.

As is now (hopefully) increasingly common knowledge, our numerous occupations in the Middle East and Africa were not sparked by those countries attacking us.  Rather, with the possible exception of the War in Afghanistan — which has lasted an outrageously long time with huge costs of both blood and treasure, our 5+ wars are unwarranted wars of aggression rendered unconstitutional by their lack of official declaration by the Congress and unaffordable by our $15 trillion national debt. 

The CIA estimates there are fewer than 100 members of al Qaeda left in Afghanistan, and yet we linger with tens of thousands of troops and hundreds of billions of dollars spent.  Recall also that many of the people we’re fighting there we were training just a few decades years ago, possibly including even bin Laden himself.

We’re finally pulling out of Iraq, left unstable and arguably more dangerous than we found it — not to mention the hundreds of thousands of excess civilian deaths our intervention has caused there.

In Libya, we’re not really sure who we supported or if the new government will even be friendly to us.  Many of the rebels we helped are backed by al Qaeda, our enemies just a few countries away.

In Pakistan, our drone operations are permitted to kill 50 civilians — including women and children — for every one terrorist they get, and no one is required to report to the public who is killed.

In Somalia, we’re engaging in covert operations in a dangerous and morally dubious situation which is none of our business and stretches our military — already posted in 900 bases in more than 130 nations around the world — almost thinner than it can stand.

Now, one might argue that it’s somehow OK for the U.S. to engage in this kind of global military expansion, because we’re the good guys, right?  But, as I’ve shown, in many cases we haven’t the foggiest clue who the good guys are, and often end up doing more harm than good to our own defense in the long term.  Perhaps more importantly, how would we like it if we were on the other end of our clumsy, bloody, and expensive foreign policy?  A little consideration of the golden rule might go a long way

Originally published on my blog here.

Brian Beyer's picture
By Brian Beyer at 12:54PM

One More War: Why the Hell Not?

Cross posted at the Antiwar.com blog. Come and check it out!

A new expose from the Nation by Jeremy Scahill detailing the CIA’s same, old dirty tricks is certainly troubling. Candidate Obama assured the American public that extrajudicial actions by the CIA and Defense Department were a thing of the past. Transparency, much like hope and change, were buzz words that were constantly used to show everybody that the era of Bush was over. A new ethical era was to take hold in the White House, and would be anchored by Nancy Pelosi’s vow to oversee a Congress of integrity.

Just as Obama campaigned to make the most sweeping changes when it came to the realm of foreign policy (Guantanamo Bay, ending the war in Iraq, ending torture, etc.), it was in foreign policy that he became the most like Bush. In fact, many would argue that Obama has not only continued many of Bush’s odious practices, but has institutionalized all of these practices because of his refusal to change course.

While the secret prison that was discussed in length surely was troubling, it almost seems like the least of worries when compared to some of the statements made by officials concerning future plans for Somalia. And yes, that comparison still holds for a prison “infested with bedbugs and mosquitoes” that result in prisoners getting rashes, prompting them to “scratch themselves incessantly.”


Read more here
Shaun Bowen's picture
By Shaun Bowen at 11:07AM

Knocking Down Strawmen

I'm sure many of you, minarchist and anarchist alike, have been unfairly labeled as "wanting to institute a Somalia style situtation" in America simply for wanting less regulation. Here is a great interview clip with Pete Leeson of George Mason University addressing this strawman argument that always seems to arise.

Roy Antoun's picture
By Roy Antoun at 11:57AM

Somalian Blowback

The NY Times reported today that Somalia has been experiencing more violent turmoil as its Shabab militant group has continued the exponential harassment of local populations “to turn Somalia into a seventh-century-style Islamic state.”

What was extremely troubling, however, was “the American military providing intelligence and logistical support” for the Somali government. Although Shabab is working closely with Al Qaeda, America has yet to learn anything from blowback. Al Qaeda’s operations in Somalia are aimed to target the Somali government and have nothing to do with the security of the United States. Furthermore, Shabab and Al Qaeda’s strive to gain a foothold in Somalia are slowly failing, not because of American interventionism, but because of what the NY Times reported to be the populace “now whispering valuable secrets about the Shaba’s movements into the ears of government soldiers.” Additionally, “defectors are leaving the Shabab in droves,” while the “young men joined the local militia” to fend off Shabab fighters. 

Evidently, Somalia is able to fend for itself.


Read more here
Drew Smith's picture
By Andrew Smith at 8:42PM

Haiti: the next Somalia?

Today the French government accused the United States of occupying Haiti with military forces. While I certainly wouldn't trust the French government any more than I would the United States government, I find it hard to believe Bob Gates' defense of the US presence within Haiti

See, this isn't the first time that the United States was sent into a third world country to "provide security" for international operations. It happened in Somalia 20 years ago. Then the UN was sending humanitarian aid in light of the Somali Civil War. The US sent in Army Rangers to provide protection for the UN's aid packages. Somehow that mission transformed into Delta Force being sent in to take out the leader of the country and UN forces attempting to occupy the nation. Many men and women died on both sides.

Haiti is in a strikingly similar state as Somalia was. The government is largely insolvent; gangs of men march the streets; food is short. Is it too hard to imagine that our government would make the same mistake again? I sincerely hope that somehow in the midst of this incredible incompetence the people of Haiti do get some help, but I'm not holding my breath for the government to get something right. 

Bonnie Kristian's picture
By Bonnie Kristian at 7:12AM

Obama vows to bring "every element" of U.S. power against terrorists. Great.

Speaking in response to the recent terror attacks, the president said:

"We will not rest until we find all who were involved and hold them accountable."

"We will continue to use every element of our national power to disrupt, to dismantle and defeat the violent extremists who threaten us, whether they are from Afghanistan or Pakistan, Yemen or Somalia, or anywhere where they are plotting attacks against the U.S. homeland," Obama added.

This is no doubt meant to be encouraging to us, to assure us all that the "administration is doing enough to contain security threats."  But let's consider what this actually means in practice.

Most immediately, it means that Obama has ordered the airport security process to be reviewed.  If it's found to be wanting, as I have a sneaking suspicion it will be, we'll probably get to enjoy arriving at the airport three hours early instead of two.


Read more here
Bonnie Kristian's picture
By Bonnie Kristian at 6:00PM

US Invades Somalia

Thanks to Antiwar.com for the coverage -- I've barely seen this mentioned anywhere else; even Google News is burying it among the lesser headlines.

Following confirmation by the French military that they definitely weren’t in the process of invading Somalia, the United States military is now confirming that it is, in fact, American forces that are pouring into the southern portion of the country in a helicopter-backed invasion.

US military officials confirmed to the Associated Press today that forces from the US Joint Special Operations Command had invaded the lawless African nation, and were the ones responsible for the attack on the tiny village of Barawe this morning that was the first staging ground of the attack.

Read more here.  Yay for what might be the beginning of another long, drawn out, unnecessary, bloody, expensive, bloody expensive, and altogether miserable war.  I can only hope and pray that it isn't.  Three cheers for...freedom?

Justin Head's picture
By Justin Head at 3:26PM

Somalia's Problem: Too Much Government?

Big government supporters have been quick to point to Somalia as what happens when government is relinquished and the free market is allowed to run wild. Well as it turns out, these big government supporters are not paying attention to history (surprise, surprise). Go here to read Jesse Walker's article for Reason Magazine discussing the bloody history of Somalia.

Read more here
Bonnie Kristian's picture
By Bonnie Kristian at 6:01PM

W's Hand-Me-Downs

The similarity between the ideas motivating Mr. Obama's foreign policy of "change" and that of his predecessor has become apparent even to GQ, which apparently does more than inform men of how many buttons should be on their suits and what George Clooney has for breakfast:


Read more here
Matt Fay's picture
By Matt Fay at 10:10PM

Why Do They Hate America's Military?

For all their talk of "supporting the troops" -- which is nothing more than a pernicious cover to stop short any criticism of their policies and militarist ideology -- neoconservatives sure do want to see America's soldiers in harm's way as much as possible. That, of course, is the only conclusion I can now come to after watching the neocons work to falsify intelligence to bring about the Iraq War, agitate for war with Iran, change political allegiance to cheerlead President Obama's recent escalation of the war in Afghanistan, and, now, call for an invasion of Somalia. Discussing the rec
Read more here