David Frum's Critique Is Far From Sound

In his weekly CNN column, David Frum argues that "Ron Paul's money plan is far from golden," but makes a lot of mistakes in his analysis.

He uses the same tired, old, and refuted Keynesian argument that a free monetary system based on gold currency is too inflexible. He argues the Great Depression happened because the gold standard prevented the government from being able to expand the monetary supply to get us out of the economic recession.

His prescription for avoiding the Great Depression is the Keynesian idea that the Federal Reserve should print up money out of nothing to extend credit to the government (by purchasing Treasury bonds), and that the government could then ramp up spending to stimulate the economy. Frum argues that this could not occur in 1929 because of the gold standard, and the economic contraction slipped into a full-blown depression without government stimulus.

Frum believes, like the defunct Keynes, that a government-sponsored central banking system can ease busts by expanding the money supply, and then take the excess money back out during booms when the growing economy can safely absorb the monetary contraction. This necessarily assumes that you won't have high inflation during an economic recession.