Posts in "iraq"

Seth Mann's picture
By Seth Mann at 5:44PM

How do we know when WikiLeaks has it wrong?

EDIT: This post is not calling into question the video discussed elsewhere on the YALiberty blog.

How do we know when WikiLeaks has it wrong?

Bonnie's post has me thinking of the circumstances around which I first learned of WikiLeaks.

Sometime after I was initiated into a fraternity, I learned that its Ritual had been posted at WikiLeaks.  This was interesting for a time, but after perusing an official copy of the Ritual in person and comparing it to the document posted at WikiLeaks, there were glaring discrepancies.  Neither I nor any other member of my fraternity would feel especially threatened by an outsider reading our Ritual because it must be experienced to be understood and the Ritual as written leaves certain words, phrases, and descriptions blanked out so that they can only be passed on via word of mouth.

WikiLeaks has uncovered scandal and stores raw information that might otherwise be removed from the internet.  For those fighting for transparency it is indeed a valuable resource.  If I were to speculate, I would guess that public trust in the information released via Wikileaks is much higher than public trust in the nightly news reports.  But, as in the case of my fraternity's Ritual, how do we know when WikiLeaks has it wrong?

Posted in:
William Stewart's picture
By William Stewart-starks at 3:38PM

Cost of War Exhibit, University of Kansas YAL

flag display

YAL members at the University of Kansas wanted to do something big to speak out against the continued occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan and present a non-interventionist foreign policy to the student body.  An idea from the past is slowly turning into a traveling display across the state of Kansas where YAL chapters are teaming up with local activist groups to present a flag memorial for service-members lost and a forum to discuss the cost of maintaining the US Empire.  Groups involved include:

  • Ambassadors for Peace (K-State)
  • Amnesty International (K-State)
  • Iraq Veterans Against the War/Afghanistan Veterans Against the War
  • Manhattan Alliance for Peace and Justice (Manhattan, KS)
  • Young Americans for Liberty (KU, K-State, Wichita State)
We also got some press coverage:  University Daily Kansan (article) and Lawrence Journal World (video). Other media in attendance were KUJH and the University of Kansas Alumni Magazine.

 

Sam Swedberg's picture
By Sam Swedberg at 7:51PM

Petition to End the Wars Month: Wichita State

Wichita State held a Petition to End the Wars event this past Wednesday and Thursday.  They were able to interact with a number of students; Wichita State YAL's president, Andrew Cranmer, wrote an account of the event here.

Here are some highlights:

Obama's War

 Open Poster

File Attachments
67.48 KB

Read more here
Sam Swedberg's picture
By Sam Swedberg at 11:27AM

Petition to End the Wars Month: Middle Tennessee State's War Memorial

On Wednesday, March 24th, Middle Tennessee State YAL held a memorial for the Tennessean troop lives lost in the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars.  They also held a memorial for the civilian lives lost in the Iraq War.


Read more here
Jackie Silseth's picture
By Jackie Silseth at 7:14AM

St. Cloud Chapter Hosts Successful Anti-War Event!

On Wednesday the St. Cloud State University YAL chapter hosted an event to petition against the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan barely twelve hours after making an appearance at the College Republicans' event "Why Am I Conservative?" making an effort to outeach to both the fiscal and social conservative movements.

While the anti-war protest was politicized by some less classically-liberal students and the administration tried to shut us down, claiming that we had not followed procedure to secure our location, they eventually admitted that they had a reservation for the group. "Student groups aren't allowed to post things to the building," said a man from the programming office, "But those cement walls over there are fine."

Despite the red tape and some student-group politics, our chapter managed to collect more than 250 signatures in support of H.R. 248 - to present to our Representative, Michele Bachmann - while increasing our group size 50% in a single day.

The Crew Setting Up at Locale #1


Read more here
Preston Mui's picture
By Preston Mui at 8:33AM

Blast from the Past

7 years ago today:

Bush warned the nation that the conflict "could be longer and more difficult than some predict."

But he assured Americans that "this will not be a campaign of half-measures, and we will accept no outcome except victory.

We have no ambition in Iraq, except to remove a threat and restore control of that country to its own people," he said.

Bush also told Americans that "helping Iraqis achieve a united, stable and free country will require our sustained commitment."

To celebrate, I caught a late-night showing of Green Zone, which centers around an American soldier searching for WMDs and the truth behind the bad intelligence leading up to the invasion. Near the end, one of the Iraqis tells him, "It is not up to you to decide what happens here."

Posted in:
Bonnie Kristian's picture
By Bonnie Kristian at 1:37PM

"Bad things may happen in Iraq if we pull out. And they will happen anyway if we stay."

Indeed, they will.  Ron Paul's simple argument that "we just walked in; we can just walk out" of our foolish involvements in the Middle East continue to ring true -- and the fact that we can just pull out of Iraq and Afghanistan is well argued by Tom Englehardt at the American Conservative:

We’ve now been at war with, or in, Iraq for almost 20 years, and intermittently at war in Afghanistan for 30 years. Think of it as nearly half a century of experience, all bad.

And yet, despite claims from the administration that the war is on its decline (claims which may or may not prove reliable and, even at best, will not result in a complete withdrawal of American involvement from Iraq), we still have a large military presence in Iraq, and many still contend that we need to continue it:

The Iraqis, so the argument goes, need us.... In the year to come, based on what we’re seeing now, such arguments may intensify. Terrible prophecies about Iraq’s future without us may multiply. And make no mistake, terrible things could indeed happen in Iraq.


Read more here
Dustin Reid's picture
By Dustin Reid at 9:11PM

Alan Grayson: "We Won in Iraq & Afghanistan!"

I wish this guy was in step with the liberty movement because on issues we agree on no one makes more convincing arguments.

Roy Antoun's picture
By Roy Antoun at 1:21PM

When holding the hammer...

"When neither their property nor their honor is touched, the marjority of men live content." - Niccolo Machiavelli

As the United States continues to hold a hammer, everything looks more and more like a nail.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict seems like an ancient battle between good and evil, where both good and evil are relative to the agent.  But people often misname the crisis:  It should be read “The Israeli-American-Palestinian Conflict” with “American” strategically sandwiched in between the original two contenders. The Middle East has continued to be a hotbed of problems because of unnecessary involvement ever since the West chose to divvy the Ottoman Empire rather than allowing each region to claim its own sovereignty as America did during and after its Revolution. Rather than witnessing the natural evolution of states, the West forced state boundaries, leading to many of the problems we have today.


Read more here
Roy Antoun's picture
By Roy Antoun at 11:26PM

Never Ending Nation Builders

Prime Minister Gordon Brown testified that he supported and still supports the war in Iraq, but only wished it had an exit strategy or a reconstruction strategy that actually gained the favor of the Iraqi people. Although a step forward from what the neoconservatives of the past decade vehemently supported in the U.S., Mr. Brown's justification for the war from the start was declaring that Iraq was a threat that "had to be dealt with." At this rate, the United States and its singular Western ally can call anything a "threat" and "deal with it."

Threats do not necessarily need a massive invasion or quasi- military occupation. If Saddam Hussein was a threat and his people were not, couldn't a simple Delta Force operation "deal" with him? Can't a Delta Force, Navy Seal, or Spec. Ops. team deal with any terrorist cell better than a standing army can, twiddling its thumbs in open desert, angering the indigenous population? Mr. Brown was right -- there was no exit strategy; however, there was no real strategy to begin with and what Gordon Brown fails to admit is that there was no overall strategy because the war in Iraq was essentially an expansion of the American empire, adding just another one of our global military bases to the collection of over 700 that we have right now.

There was no strategy or exit strategy because, I fear, the plan was to simply dump American troops in another location and leave them there as a showcase of American hard power.