Raising Consciousness beyond the Political Means

Johnny Harrelson
Aug 16, 2013 at 5:59 PM

I propose in the following discussion to call one's own labor and the equivalent exchange of one's own labor for the labor of others, the "economic means" for the satisfaction of need while the unrequited appropriation of the labor of others will be called the "political means."

— Franz Oppenheimer, The State

On a recent trip to Arlington, Virginia for the 5th Annual YAL National Convention a question was asked by one of the speakers: “How many of you are political science majors?”

The vast majority of the hands in the room went up.  I found this phenomenon exceedingly interesting.  As a matter of fact, one could certainly understand why Young Americans for Liberty, a group founded for the purpose of political activism in youth circles, would attract university students who also happen to be political science majors, and who also most likely have ambitions for professional life.

Yet what does this represent?  Is the goal of liberty a purely political goal?

Liberty certainly is the essence of what Oppenheimer termed the economic means.  Such as it is, can a political movement, based on the ‘economic means’ of voluntary exchange, property rights, self-defense, etc. achieve a goal which is antithetical to the very means which it has professed to abolish?

It is impossible not to come to the conclusion that, in order to make an allowance for the political means, that by degrees we must neglect the ultimate goal of the economic means, which is liberty.

This being said, it is crucial to understand the political means in terms of an overall strategy for liberty.  Pursing liberty via its antithetical political means could best be described as what Murray Rothbard termed ‘right opportunism;’ a strategy defined as activism pushed forward by a series of short run gains and compromises. As an overall strategy there is certainly room for the political means. The political means must be infiltrated. It must be delegitimized. It must be dismantled and it must be thrust out of the realm of human action in order for humanity to elevate to a more perfect, moral, and free state of being. Yet, to focus solely on the political means as an end towards the liberation of humanity is shortsighted and ultimately doomed to fail.

The use of political means by economic oriented activists, proto-libertarians, classical liberals, and principled statesmen of the past, did so initially as an earnest attempt to create a more just and free society, yet as fiction writer Frank Herbert aptly proclaimed “every revolutionary is a closet aristocrat.”

This comment, although flip and overtly cynical, does cautiously and succinctly point toward a history filled with several moral revolutions, rooted in the economic morality of voluntary exchange, property rights, and justice; which in time had grown only to be subdued by the seduction of political power.  From the Leveller Movement to the Reagan Revolution, history is filled with political movements that professed a vision grounded in the defense of the economic means against the political means, yet all too often, did more to perpetuate and grow the political means at the latter’s expense.

The point is all too clear.  For if the ultimate goal of Liberty, as a vision and as a code for a free and just society is the north star, the guiding light for a Liberty activist, it must be unequivocally understood that the State, the organization of the political means to accumulate wealth and power, ultimately will fail the test to live up to the principles of a free and voluntary society.

Yet, if the future of the Liberty movement is predominantly dominated by political scientists; either with ambitions to demonstrate their profession in practice, or to create and perpetuate a cadre of a new political elite, it must be understood that this fledgling cadre of vanguard professionals, if they are successful in the cause, at some point will have to make a choice between the political means and the economic means of sustaining themselves.

Politics is war without bloodshed while war is politics with bloodshed.

— Mao Zedong

In war, especially a just war, there must be designs for victory.  What are the terms, conditions, and desired outcomes?  When will an activist or a movement know that they’ve succeeded?  When Liberty is achieved?  When will the political vanguard make an exodus from the political realm and use their organizational skills for the benefit of a voluntary society?   It is the tendency of political classes to perpetuate the political means for as long as possible.  Prestige, wealth, and power; all the things which afflict the human condition, tend to aggrandize itself more potently in the realm of politics. 

What should be done to guard against this familiar matter of fact?  Will this incarnation of the Liberty movement have room for the apolitical?  Or will it assert itself by descending into doublespeak and self-aggrandizement?

I contend that the liberty movement and Young Americans for Liberty in particular, should devote more time and spread its reach into the realm of the apolitical. Entrepreneurs, engineers, scientists, chemists, artists, and those devoted to the productive, economic means of procuring wealth.  It is here on the cutting edge of human development where the ‘disruptive’ advancement of our culture and our humanity progresses. As a matter of fact, great gains in liberty almost never come from the political sphere of human society.  The Gutenberg Press, the airplane, William Shakespeare, etc. — all of the riches of the free human soul be they material, intellectual, or spiritual have rarely came by way of the political means. 

Furthermore, I urge that more work be done to enlarge the cadre of Liberty activists beyond the insulated world of politics and make it a point to stretch and elevate the consciousness of humanity far beyond the self-induced limits of using the political means to an end.  Reaching out to engineering majors, technology majors, tradesmen, chemists, and scientists; those young men and women who are working in fields which can do more to disrupt the status quo than any political movement are vital to focus the cause of liberty and sharpen its effect on our local, national, and global communities.  These are the innovators who even now will inherit and further pioneer the way for such 'disruptive' technologies as 3D printing, information encryption, and alternative currencies.

The great men of liberty have understood this need and have offered several examples about the ways in which humanity is furthered by a just economic system and the ways in which political efforts as a sole means to an end usually ends badly.

Ludwig von Mises, in a letter written to F.A. Hayek, laid out the reasons for the failure of liberty-minded activists in their efforts to effectively stop the growth of fascism and national socialism before the second World War:

The cause of this lamentable failure was that the founders of these movements could not emancipate themselves from the sway of the very ideas of the foes of liberty. They did not realize that freedom is inextricably linked with the market economy. 

Again we see Franz Oppenheimer’s common sense dialectic between the economic means and the political means at work in this exchange. 

The greater point is this.  That while the political means does have a role to play in the greater strategy for the ultimate end towards liberty and a free society; every political scientist, every student who is banking on a long career in politics, be it on K Street or in a state house somewhere, if that person is to be honest with themselves and honest with the Liberty movement to which they profess a sincere and shared goal, must also understand that the state of political affairs are only temporary.   It must be understood that sooner or later, such a person will either work to break the hold the state has on society or they will succumb to it, justify their role in it, and may turn out like our favorite Goldwater girl, Hillary Clinton

Use politics, but use wisely.

Content published on the Young Americans for Liberty blog is only representative of the opinions and research of the individual authors. It does not necessarily reflect the views, goals, or membership of YAL. 

There are two fundamentally opposed means whereby man, requiring sustenance, is impelled to obtain the necessary means for satisfying his desires. These are work and robbery, one’s own labor and the forcible appropriation of the labor of others. Robbery! Forcible appropriation! These words convey to us ideas of crime and the penitentiary, since we are the contemporaries of a developed civilization, specifically based on the inviolability of property. And this tang is not lost when we are convinced that land and sea robbery is the primitive relation of life, just as the warriors’ trade—which also for a long time is only organized mass robbery—constitutes the most respected of occupations. Both because of this, and also on account of the need of having, in the further development of this study, terse, clear, sharply opposing terms for these very important contrasts, I propose in the following discussion to call one’s own labor and the equivalent exchange of one’s own labor for the labor of others, the “economic means” for the satisfaction of needs, while the unrequited appropriation of the labor of others will be called the “political means.”

Greetings,

Adam Gottbetter

adamg's picture

it's nice to hear about the younger generation taking an interest in politics.

More Info Here

Balairat's picture

I was looking at my collection of books on one of my many teak bookcases and ended up thinking about this very thing. So now I'm here reading this and I must say, this is really well written. Nice job, Johnny.

MichelleV's picture

Thanks Johnny for great written. I just search about this field from Minnesota Design company. I really happy to get this post...hope to see more post about this topic from you in next time.

katiegray's picture

This article is best in my personal opinion. The details are offered with intelligent thought and also consideration. It is rather very nicely written and intriguing. Thank you for delivering this kind of useful information.

Visit me at Vinity Soft Inc. for best software development solution for business.

 
jerryshaw's picture

Hi Friend, My Name Is "Saman" I am Expert in blogcommenting and link building for the last 3 years in Marketing Agency Under. All the links will be powerful and on actual page. Any Questions For Me So Please Conversations High Quality DoFollow Blog Comment Service

alikhan_095's picture

I like viewing web sites which comprehend the price of delivering the excellent useful resource free of charge. I truly adored reading your posting. Thank you! instagram followers

alikhan_095's picture

I will return and review your article later on to explore the perfect landscapes you have mentioned. It is an informative article that I could really sink my teeth into.

Regards,

Jerry @ How to use no no

jerryshaw's picture

It has always been like that. Also, you can check the instagram followers free website. Isn't that cool?

Emilio's picture

The first version of the Girlfriend System was a 7-part video course that quickly gained a cult-like following from men looking for more than just casual flings with women. www.sgdatingweb.com/gfas-review-how-the-girlfriend-activation-system-attracts-women

leijon19's picture

The book examines many of the claims made about coconut oil, reviews the scientific evidence supporting and refuting these claims, and provides an in-depth overview of coconut oil and how to use it daily to improve health in a variety of ways.kusi.com

leijon19's picture

At the end of the day, I believe it's the consumer's responsibility to do their own due diligence before investing in any program, but I definitely want to share with you what I've discovered during my own research in case it helps.https://rebelmouse.com/thetruthaboutcellulitereview

leijon19's picture

This is a natural and efficient by a special formula , after years of study and draft . You Know these top treatment is directly related to the presence of unique natural ingredients.勃起功能障碍-如何选择最好的自然保健品

 
leijon19's picture

dr oz forskolin extract Much appreciated a whole lot for this extraordinary article;this is the stuff that keeps me experiencing out these day. pure garcinia cambogia extract

jimmy121's picture

This statement runs counter to all of the ‘be happy with your size’ marketing and advertising that is so prevalent in today’s magazines and television commercials, but it is true.www.rebelmouse.com/venusfactorsystemreview/

Asad Yousuf's picture

Perfect Vision Today: Dr. Sen And Samantha Pearson Reveal A Breakthrough, Step-By-Step System To Achieve 20/20 Vision And Help Cure Myopia, Hyperopia, Presbyopia, And Most Other Visual Problems In As Little As 2 Weeks...Leonard

Asad Yousuf's picture

As a lead reviewer and editor for TheOfficialWebsite.co, I’ve examined hundreds of digital ebooks online and have become pretty proficient at separating legitimate product reviews from fake ones. you can get rid of herpes

leijon19's picture

Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for.

backlinks

johnb6174's picture

This site is a leading resource for information about the Michael Griswold M3 System PDF book and ex recovery guide that teaches you cutting-edge, psychological triggers for getting your ex girlfriend or ex boyfriend to miss you and want you back without resorting to worn-out tactics that don't work like "convincing" or manipulation.https://www.rebelmouse.com/

Asad Yousuf's picture

Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, I want to encourage that you continue your great job, have a good day.News

leijon19's picture

The internet is really the most accessible as well as the most important medium of communication as well as information dissemination in these modern times.what to do for earache

Asad Yousuf's picture

I figure I'll probably want a girlfriend sooner or later. Should I start dating someone this year or enjoy my last year at school single? I guess I'm worried that once I'm out of school I'll be just be trying to meet girls in bars and shiit and that'll suck. easiest way to impress any woman

leijon19's picture

As a Newbie, I am permanently exploring online for articles that can be of assistance to me. Thank you
dr oz garcinia cambogia

jimmy121's picture

The Penguin Method is the key to creating a powerful, unspoken connection with your man that won't fade with time and a scientifically proven way to get him to commit to you both physically and emotionally...5 easy steps to get him to propose

leijon19's picture

 

I am not sure where you’re getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for excellent information I was looking for this information for my mission... clash of clans hack

Colithat's picture

Joan is not the only mathematical whiz kid to have been “lucky” enough to win big on the lottery but the others are too numerous to mention. I think you get the picture though.www.lottery-winning.com

Asad Yousuf's picture

Everything is very open with a clear description of the issues. It was definitely informative. Your website is extremely helpful. Many thanks for sharing! See more about fleet management software.

jerryshaw's picture

Better yet, stop what you’re doing right now and really take some time to learn exactly what it takes to attract the most attractive and most popular girl in any room, get her to date you, and ultimately turn her into your girlfriend.the social man girlfriend activation system download

Asad Yousuf's picture

Fibroids Miracle: Amanda Leto Reveals Her Strangely Effective, 3-Step Holistic System For Safely, Naturally, And Permanently Curing Uterine Fibroids, No Surgery Required...treatment for uterine fibroids without surgery

Asad Yousuf's picture

The emotional contagion concept that Dr. T. teaches is based on actual scientific research that makes it possible for you to make your emotions contagious to her, much like how a yawn by someone in a room can be contagious and can cause everyone else in the room to also yawn.buy the desire system

Asad Yousuf's picture

If you go to a restaurant, pay for the meal. If you go to the movies, pay for both tickets. Yeah, it’s the 21st century and everything, but if you’re trying to attract a woman, you have to show that you’re interested enough in her to “invest” in the potential relationship.does the girlfriend activation system actually work

Asad Yousuf's picture

I want to take you inside Mike’s system and share with you some of the reasons why using your cell phone to tap out a few simple text messages can have a dramatic impact on your relationship.the text your ex back system

Asad Yousuf's picture

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work read this get my ex to fall in love with me again

leijon19's picture

Great stuff from you, man. Ive read your stuff before and you're just too awesome. I love what you've got here, love what you're saying and the way you say it. Guaranteed Outcome

jimmy121's picture

I am continually scanning online for articles that can help me. There is clearly a ton to think about this. I think you made some great focuses in Features additionally. Continue working, incredible occupation!
Fort Meyers Waterfront

jimmy121's picture

Awesome dispatch! I am indeed getting apt to over this info, is truly neighborly my buddy. Likewise fantastic blog here among many of the costly info you acquire. Reserve up the beneficial process you are doing here. Marketing 1on1

jimmy121's picture

Regular visits here are the best way to thank you for your effort, which is the reason why I'm visiting the site everyday, looking for new, interesting info. Many, many thanks! creative ways to encourage potty training

HELENAJAMES's picture

The first several months of my site there were no comments; just give it time; now they come in like crazy every day! Thanks.
Avocado Oil

HELENAJAMES's picture

Thank you for posting such a great article! I found your website perfect for my needs. www.doneassignment.co.uk/write-my-assignment.php It contains wonderful and helpful posts. Keep up the good work! 

Bryan7's picture

The latest version of the Girlfriend Activation System (GFAS V2), a 23 part video-based seminar experience gives men the skillsets, techniques, inner game, and step-by-step instructions they need to not only attract a beautiful girlfriend, but to nurture and develop that relationship for the long-term. Main points of the GFAS program focus on understanding the concept of a woman’s “obsession story” and teaching men how to successfully navigate through every phase of the dating process.how to get the girlfriend activation system for free

Asad Yousuf's picture

I read this article. I think You put a great deal of exertion to make this article. I like your work. Opzioni Binarie

jimmy121's picture

Thank you so much for this very usefull information. It's just a very effectively written article. voyance directe

leijon19's picture

poster's site I most likely appreciating each and every bit of it. It is an incredible site and decent impart. I need to much obliged. Great employment! You all do an incredible blog, and have some extraordinary substance. Keep doing awesome. top rated

jimmy121's picture

Nice share of information here. I really find this information really helpful for me. Thanks a lot, dude, for putting up this vital information on the internet for everybody to use. Kickboxing in Ashburn, VA

jimmy121's picture

I was extremely satisfied to discover this site.i needed to thank you for this extraordinary read!! I doubtlessly getting a charge out of every last bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you post. כהן פקס ברוש

jimmy121's picture

One of the main reasons why guys get the “first date jitters” is because they don’t have a definite game plan in place before they go out with a girl.best way to make a girl your girlfriend

Asad Yousuf's picture

I should assert barely that its astounding! The blog is informational also always fabricate amazing entitys.
Guaranteed Outcome

jimmy121's picture

I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things.
http://www.dr-oz-fat-burner.com

jimmy121's picture

I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things.
vorwärts

jimmy121's picture

SEO {has become|is becoming|is now|has grown to be} {quite a|a significant|a serious|a good} house hold name with countless {business owners|business people|companies|businesses} {choosing to|deciding to|determining to|opting to} implement this seemingly effective {online marketing|internet marketing|website marketing|web marketing} tool {in to|directly into|into|straight into} their websites. Sadly enough, {a great number of|a lot of|many|a large number of} {people don't|individuals don't|folks don't|people do not} {seem to|appear to|manage to|apparently} know {what it is|what it's|how it's|how it is} or {what it|what it really|exactly what it|just what it} even does. {Reason why|Reason|Reasons why|Good reason that} {the following|the next|these|the subsequent} read is {dedicated to|focused on|committed to|specialized in} explaining what SEO {in Toronto|working in Toronto|Toronto|inside Toronto} {is all about|is about|is focused on|is centered on} and {how it works|how it operates|the ins and outs|the way it operates} to benefit {a website|an internet site|a web site|an online site}.best seo toronto

Asad Yousuf's picture