Welcome to the new Young Americans for Liberty! Learn about the new features or give us your feedback!

Just Sue the Bastards

Shaun Bowen
Jul 24, 2010 at 5:31 PM

Everyone knows the newspaper industry is in financial trouble. Low readership has put many newspapers out of business and the big guys like the New York Times and Washington Post are dying to change business models and turn a profit. Should we go all digital? Should we charge for digital copies like The Times Online has started (which has actually killed their online presence)?

But why change business models when you can just sue your way back into the black? In a new strategy, borrowed heavily from the music and movie industry, Steve Gibson of Righthaven has been buying copyrights to news chains and suing bloggers for "stealing" content. According to Gibson,

"We believe it’s the best solution out there,” Gibson says. “Media companies’ assets are very much their copyrights. These companies need to understand and appreciate that those assets have value more than merely the present advertising revenues.”

Now I know that the libertarian discussion of intellectual property rages on still today, but if there is one thing we can agree upon it is that posting stories on your blog from newspapers should not fall under copyright law.

This new strategy not only will bankrupt innocent people but it will also stifle free speech. Gibson is current taking action against the conspiracy site Abovetopsecret.com, a user generated site, for hosting an article posted by a user. Websites like the Drudge Report, Raw Story, and others that almost exclusively link to other news sites could be threatened as well.

Gibson currently has filed over 80 lawsuits for his clients and is working on more.   I wonder what this means for YALiberty.org?

The work that reporters and editors do is worth a lot of money, the problem with reposting their articles is that another person gets to grab the readership that those writers and reporters do a lot of work to inform and so grab the advertising dollars that they need to go on writing and reporting.  Linking sites that send readers back to the original source don't seem to be a huge problem to me because the publications can still sell advertising on the articles. But to those who would sell the blood, sweat and tears of hard working newsmen as their own, good riddance.  It stifles free speech to stop professionals from doing the important reporting that keeps our nations leaders accountable and our citizens informed.  Never forgot your patron saint Ayn Rand's lesson, we will not work for free, and we will not let you steal what is ours.

's picture

I don't think this is talking about stealing an article and not crediting the source, but about taking a quote and linking back to the original source.  Most people in news want their articles to be cited with links wherever possible to boost their traffic.

Bonnie Kristian's picture