Welcome to the new Young Americans for Liberty! Learn about the new features or give us your feedback!

It's Not About Guns; It's About Speech

Wesley Messamore
Jun 30, 2010 at 6:04 PM

Are these institutions Private or Public?  If they are public, I agree that students should have the legal right to carry on campus.  If they are private institutions I would make the argument that the private institution has the legal right to choose if they will allow students to carry on campus or not.

's picture

Oh definitely.  That's a basic result of their (private schools') private property rights.

Bonnie Kristian's picture

I'd bet it actually is about guns to some degree.

I don't know the ins and outs of free speech requirements at different kinds of colleges and universities, but at my university it was always a hotbed of controversy. Umpteen million political, religious, and lifestyle groups always wanted to spread their message any way they wanted. There was a lot of pushing the envelope in the area of civility. The university allowed almost any group and any message, but they were expected to restrict their activities in certain ways so as not harrass or interfere with the day-to-day business of the university.

Although it may be irrational and not entirely fair toward the pro-gun groups, guns on campus make a lot of people afraid. And this is where free speech starts to bleed over into crying fire in the theater. I would think there's a wiser way to approach this discussion than frightening people. In a similar vein, I wouldn't want an anti-abortionist chasing me down the sidewalk shaking a bloody, rubber fetus in my face.

Brien Wright's picture

There are all kinds of things that could make me uncomfortable to see someone say or do in public, but I'd never make their first amendment rights conditional upon my level of comfort with what they're saying- otherwise I don't believe in free speech after all.

Wes Messamore's picture

Yeah, I don't think you have a right not to get your feelings hurt.  Not to be assualted, yes; not to be criminally targeted for harrassment, yes; or not to have your property damaged, yes.  But not to feel afraid?  That can't be a right.  Just imagine where the logical conclusion of that stance could lead.

Bonnie Kristian's picture