Reuters reports that bulk stores have been getting a boost over the past few days thanks to people preparing for Hurricane Irene:
Hastings expects Home Depot to do well, as it has 35 percent more stores than Lowe’s Cos Inc (LOW.N) in the affected region. He also expects Newell Rubbermaid Inc (NWL.N) to benefit from demand for storage containers.
Newell shares rose about 1 percent on Friday. Among battery makers, Energizer Holdings Inc (ENR.N) was up almost 2 percent, and Spectrum Brand Holdings (SPB.N) gained nearly 3 percent.
Drugstores and grocery stores should also see a sales lift.
“It helps the supermarkets most because people really stock up,” said BB&T Capital Markets analyst Andrew Wolf, noting Supervalu Inc’s (SVU.N) strength in Boston and Philadelphia, and Safeway Inc (SWY.N) and Ahold’s (AHLN.AS) big presence in Washington.
While sales may be boosted in these sectors, profits in other sectors — as the article does concede — may be hurt due to diverted spending.
The boost in sales of emergency supplies (and repair supplies that is sure to follow) is not some kind of wonderful economic boom to save the economy; it should not be applauded and cheered on. The boom from purchases due to Hurricane Irene all represent destroyed wealth.
This is a classic example of the Broken Window fallacy. Introduced by French political economist Frederic Bastiat, the broken window fallacy pretty much states that when wealth is destroyed (he uses the example of a baker’s window being broken), it may appear that the economy is stimulated by the expenditures to replace the wealth, but this is not so. Themoney that is used to replace the wealth could have been used to create more wealth elsewhere, while still keeping the original wealth (Bastiat uses the baker keeping the window and buying a suit). This expenditure — which would be something along the lines of school supplies or new clothes at this time of year, instead of batteries and water — may appear to help whoever supplies it, but the money could have been used to help whoever would have supplies the forgone purchases.
So, instead of having a perfectly full cabinet of food, a well-stocked fridge, a non-flooded yard, and house, and new clothes, school supplies, and other luxuries, people are stuck with emergency food supplies and a repaired house. The wealth that could have been invested in making people’s lives better was lost in preventing their lives from getting worse. Destruction is never an economic stimulus, it simply destroys wealth and prevents progress.
And to think that this is the stuff that Nobel Laureates advocate.
- Blog Policy
- Login or register to post comments
Connect with YAL
to the YAL channel on 
Upcoming Events
-
Info This seminar offers an introduction to the thoughts and thinkers of the...
-
Info The contrast between liberty and power in the history of the...
-
Info The summer’s final Freedom University boasts lectures on the hottest...
-
Info This is an all day, family-friendly convention for freedom-minded folks in...
-
Info Taking RSVP now for a June 30th - July 1st convention.We need to secure...
The Hurricane looks devastating. The Hurricane example is good to compare with the sales condition. Thanks for this wonderful post.
xtrema cookware
Sport Support Products
Radius Gauge
Wine Pouch Wholesale Fan 0.320930041
Car Mini Refrigerator
Spring Thing
Pen Holder Boomerang 0.30042367
Cleaner Products
Bag Sealer
Wholesale Calendar Pet Waste Bag Dispenser 0.968597219
Manicure Set
Wholesale Tellurion
Garden Decorations Wholesale Umbrella 0.635901668
Wholesale Towel
Wholesale Dartboard
Entertainment Supplies Wholesale Dartboard 0.410343284
Wholesale Gift Bags
Wholesale Bracelet
Voice Recorder Promotional Products 0.131256772
Mini DV
Vuvuzela
Wine Bottle Cove Wholesale Golf Products 0.112395995
Consumer Electronics
Sport Support Products
Cleaner Products Wholesale Bag 0.46991405
Wholesale Compass
Crystal Clock
Wholesale Mirror Wholesale TelePhone 0.120153362
Personal Safety Products
Promotional Gifts
Wholesale Playing Card Wholesale Glove 0.673833866
Entertainment Supplies
Consumer Electronics
Wholesale Compass Wholesale Scissors 0.253395127
Water Bottle
Wholesale Calendar
Medicine Instrument Wholesale Stapler 0.324350808
Baby Products Suppliers
Trolley Coin Card
Badge Reel Medicine Instrument 0.274952431
Corner Flag
BMI Tape Measure
Digital Photo Frame Lighting Products 0.572761079
Home Appliances
Leather Clock
Wholesale Helmet Wholesale Mat 0.008567948
Sport Support Products
Wholesale Gift Bags
Wholesale Towel Wholesale Stress Ball 0.448646757
Medicine Instrument
Eye Mask
Wholesale Jewelry Wholesale Playing Card 0.452734088
Wholesale Mirror
Baby Products Suppliers
Bottle Opener Promotional Items 0.356307128
Wholesale Bracelet
Promotional Products Giveaway Material Wholesale Clothes Rack 0.55938936
Tube Cooler
Corner Flag Wholesale Golf Products Wholesale Banner 0.334650598
The sales have been boosted a lot in these private sectors. like the Hurricane which was devastating. The example of the broken window is really exciting and very interesting. cleveland brothers caterpillar
What a wonderful post, thanks so much for sharing this with us.
canvas prints
The boost in sales of emergency supplies (and repair supplies that is sure to follow) is not some kind of wonderful economic boom to save the economy; it should not be applauded and cheered on.
wholesale ladies clothesExcellent post and wonderful blog, I really like this type of interesting articles keep it u. I am really loving the theme/design of your web site. divorce forms
You must know, your article goes to the center of the issue. Your pellucidity leaves me wanting to know more. Allow me to forthwith grab your feed to keep up to date with your web site. Saying thanks is simply my little way of saying what a masterpiece for a special resource. Accept my dearest wishes for your inflowing publication.
Orya Maqbool Jan
The ideas are strongly pointed out and clearly emphasized. Please keep posting about such articles as they really spread useful information.Essay Help UK
I impressed greatly that the way you have written such great article. I got many reference about this topic but your one is wonderful. When I started to read article I was thinking about the way you present such great topic. By the way could you please post more article on such topic ? I really appreciate it. Thanks man!Essays Help
The concept of your blog is very fresh i definitely sure the visitors who visit your will like your content and pointers. Logo Design Contest
I have been exploring for a little for any high-quality articles or weblog posts on this sort of space . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. Reading this info So i am glad to convey that I have a very excellent uncanny feeling I found out just what I needed. I most definitely will make certain to do not fail to remember
this website and give it a glance regularly .
buy steroids
We can be thankful for the bulk stores. They are doing a world of legal good.
The story you told about Irene's Broken Window is very interesting.As with all the story this is a very interesting one.Thanks for sharing it with all of us.Find name by phone number
Irene is currently in course to strike [url=http://www.lawyer-burnaby.ca/]North Carolina Saturday evening,[/url] then continue northward to the New York City area. Accuweather is currently reporting, "Such a path would lead to severe impacts that could prompt officials to force evacuations. All residents and visitors in the path of Irene should heed these orders if issued and prepare homes and businesses for Irene's onslaught in the meantime."
Correct. The full programs have admitted certain applicants and have notified those students. Pay SomeOne To Do My Essay
hurricane irren what a mess up.But fedric has given a niche thought. Durham Solicitors Good post
I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles...Buy assignment
Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share. ..Marketing Assignment
Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share. . ..Marketing Assignment
This expenditure — which would be something along the lines of school supplies or new clothes at this time of year, instead of batteries and water — may appear to help whoever supplies it, but the money could have been used to help whoever would have supplies the forgone purchases. Headway University Scam
Not Ray`s Pizza , instead of batteries and water — may appear to help whoever supplies it, but the money could have been used to help whoever would have supplies the forgone purchases
Too bad... there are so many houses abandoned when people don't have a roof... It's a sad story I mean I'm the kind of guy who buys all kinds of stuff and has a nice garden with flowers and animals and stuff. I know how important a house is and it's just ad to see how some people ended up. I saw that the mayor had this nice campaign search: junk removal boston on Google to make the city cleaner. I hope they will do the same in this sadly challenged place.