Defending the Austrian Business Cycle

Bonnie Kristian's picture
By Bonnie Kristian at 10:24PM
Robert Murphy addresses Australian economist John Quiggin's recent critique of the Austrian theory of the business cycle on the Mises Daily blog, explaining the problems with the objections coming from Quiggin, who writes:
To sum up, although the Austrian School was at the forefront of business cycle theory in the 1920s, it hasn’t developed in any positive way since then. The central idea of the credit cycle is an important one, particularly as it applies to the business cycle in the presence of a largely unregulated financial system. But the Austrians balked at the interventionist implications of their own position, and failed to engage seriously with Keynesian ideas.
The result (like orthodox Marxism) is a research program that was active and progressive a century or so ago but has now become an ossified dogma. Like all such dogmatic orthodoxies, it provides believers with the illusion of a complete explanation but cease to respond in a progressive way to empirical violations of its predictions or to theoretical objections.
Murphy is careful to note that he does not propose to hold up the Austrian theory as an infallible "work of art that has no flaws," but he provides an able and helpful defense which may be read in full here.
I figured people reading the post would be (rightly) more likely to read Murphy than Quiggin, and I wanted them to read both.
Bonnie Kristian's picture
I'm glad you spotted this blog post, its a very thorough debunking of Quggin's criticism and I was hoping someone in YAL would post it. My only question is, why would you quote a piece of Quggin's criticism as opposed to a piece of Murphy's rebuttal? It almost looks like you're promoting Quiggin as opposed to our good friend Murphy.
's picture

yes

's picture

I agree. Certain folks there are more or less stiffneck'd about new ideas. So maybe it's more social than theoretical that's the problem there. *shrugs* I try to play the friendly hippie there in absence of others.

for more info please visit:

http://thegloriousworldcup.com/index.php?title=Main_Page/
http://reggiocollab.org/index.php?title=Main_Page/

's picture

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.